Showing posts with label double standards. Show all posts
Showing posts with label double standards. Show all posts

Thursday, February 25, 2016

Millennial Entitlement


I thought I'd start this post with a picture of me and some friends from a few years back hanging around a campfire on the beach. You know, millennials doing millennial things...


It's true that I have lived a pretty good life. I have no real complaints about what life has handed me so far. This is not a "life is too hard" so feel sorry for us millennials blog post. But it's also not exactly a "we deserve to be called entitled" blog post either.

According to most sources, millennials were born anywhere from the early 1980s (such as myself) to the early 2000s. That's a pretty broad span of time. Enough time there could be parents and children who are both considered millennials. But this is not unusual for most labeled generations to span across 20 years. The difference, I might argue, is that the world is changing at a much faster pace than ever before in history. So the difference in world experience between someone in their early 30s and someone just out of high school is a vastly different world experience.

When I was growing up I did not have a cell phone, or a "social network" or even computer with internet access. Those on the other end of the millennial generation have no idea what life is like without having the internet in their pocket at all times. They don't understand that we used to make plans ahead of time to meet with friends. And if we were late, there was no way to let the other person know that we were on our way, and if our friend was late we didn't have any device to entertain us while we waited for them. Basically you had to make a bigger effort to be on time so you didn't leave your friend waiting alone somewhere (with nothing to make them look busy so creeps wouldn't try to start a conversation with them). But I am not going to complain about these advances in technology that have made life more convenient. I enjoy these devices and the services they provide. I am just trying to explain that our lifestyles have changed vastly in just a few short years. Even in college I didn't have my own computer or laptop. I had to use the computers at the computer lab - which meant getting dressed and going into public at the times the labs were open in order to do my homework. I enjoy the flexibility that advances in technology has added to my life.

I also resent the term "entitled." I think it is thrown around way too much nowadays. I wonder if the greatest generation thought that their baby boomer children were entitled when it was suddenly a cultural norm to own a car? Perhaps they did. And perhaps being labeled as "entitled" is a right of passage until the next generation is coming of age and we get to point out all of the advantages that they enjoy that we did not have.

But I think the bigger issue with the "entitlement" is not so much that millennials think they deserve things they haven't worked hard for, I think it's that in our age of information we are the most well-informed generation. The saying "ignorance is bliss" comes to mind when I think on past generations who just didn't know they could ask for more. Nowadays it is common knowledge all of the perks that certain companies allow their employees. We all know that Google has sleep pods if you need to take nap during your break time. Ebay offers gym memberships. Many other companies offer the same perks, as well as flexible schedules and work-from-home opportunities for work-life balance. The problems is that millennials know this. And so they will ask for flexible schedules at work, or the ability to work from home some of the time. They see that successful companies are able to offer this and so they'll want to explore the possibilities available at their current jobs. They may want to prove that they can be productive and get just as much, if not more, work done if you are flexible with them. After all, we all have life stuff that we try to squeeze in on the nights and weekends that we'd like to have more flexibility with.

A friend and I were having a discussion about asking for raises. Another thing noted as "millennial entitlement." She brought up the fine point that it's not our fault that nobody asked for raises twenty years ago. But now we know that we can, and have to, ask for raises and therefore we do. It's also not our fault that the cost of living continues to rise exponentially while wages have remained pretty stagnant over the last thirty years. So we aren't asking to be paid more because we're greedy and expect handouts, we just need to keep up with our living costs.

Not all of us floated through life until we graduated college and then expected a well paying job for our art degree. That is the label that we're given. But don't forget that millennials include many of those who have fought in Iraq and Afghanistan. And remember that many of us millennials also struggled with one or two minimum wage jobs to get ourselves through college, and found that two minimum wage jobs sometimes paid better than the entry level job we were given right out of college. But we needed the health benefits and wanted to start on a career path and so we've struggled to make our way. And when we ask for flexibility, it might be because we have kids, or sick parents, or any number of responsibilities at home and no way to survive without two household incomes. And we ask for raises because we've worked our asses off for sometimes three or four years without any increase in pay and we feel we've put the effort in, and it's been made clear we AREN'T just going to be handed that raise or promotion, and so we ask. We ask because we have to. We ask because we can. We ask because, you never know if you don't ask...


Sunday, December 6, 2015

New Mormon Policy on Gay Families

I have now had some time to think about the new LDS church policy and do not feel so reactionary about it. For anyone who is still unfamiliar, though I am not sure how that is possible, it is a new policy that declares anyone who is LGBT and lives in accordance with that identification (for example, are in a same sex relationship) are considered apostates. Any children living in a household (at least most of the time) with a parent or parents who are living in a same sex relationship will not be allowed full membership until they are 18 and denounce their parents' homosexuality.

Many religions have always seen homosexuality as a sin and therefore any homosexual acts as sinful. This is not new, or a surprise to anyone. But what did surprise people is the way the LDS church leadership has chosen to deal with the children of these individuals. And for me there are two big issues that arise with this new policy that seem to be in direct conflict with other Mormon and Christian doctrine.

1. Blessings, Baptism, and the Priesthood: For the church to create a policy that prevents an innocent child from receiving these ordinances they are either saying that children of a LGBT parent are not worthy, and are therefore being punished for the sins of their parents, OR they are saying that these ordinances maybe aren't as important as they seem. Because if they really were essential to an individuals exaltation then they are damning these children for something they have no control over until they are 18. But on the other hand, maybe getting blessings when you are young, and being baptized at age 8, and doing temple ordinances like baptisms for the dead when you are 12, and (if you are a boy) also getting the priesthood at age 12 really aren't that important. At least not essential at the currently typical ages. Perhaps more children should be made to wait a little longer before participating in some of these things so you can really be sure they fully understand what they are doing and that LDS doctrine is not in conflict with other beliefs they may hold. Which brings me to my second issue, which is a harder one to get around...

2. Family Conflicts: The justification the church issued for not including children of LGBT parents in these ordinances can be summed up as "for their own good." The LDS church leaders say that they do not want to cause confusion with children who are living in a household that is in direct conflict with church teachings. This sounds like a noble gesture; they want to preserve the family. Until you realize that they are actively recruiting young people who are still living with their parents to convert to the church. These are children of parents who are not members of the LDS faith. There seems to be no concern for conflicts that may arise between the belief system of a parent in a heterosexual relationship and what the LDS doctrine teaches. Now those parents have to give permission for a child to be baptized if they are under 18. But the opportunity still is there for these children to be baptized with parental permission where this is not the case for children of LGBT parents. Is the LDS church going to agree to not recruit the children of non-members, or even the children of members who are not living in accordance with the doctrine? If this was truly their goal, then they should also have a policy not to recruit anyone under the age of 18.

I think this is why many people are struggling with the new policy on both sides of the church. For those who are not active members or were on the verge of leaving anyway, this is just one more example of the church showing exclusion and discrimination before love and acceptance. Which is hard to co-exist with the broader Christian beliefs that the LDS church is supposed to be based on. But the other side that is struggling are the true believers. They believe that this is inspired doctrine whether we understand it or not. However, it is not an easy policy to understand and so once again these true believers have to act as the apologists for the church. They try to reiterate the messages from the leadership that attempt to explain why these policies are good. But at the same time the LDS church teaches that we have agency, and we should be able to tell right from wrong, and even that we only need to rely on these feelings to know that the church is true. So if this policy is good, and from God, shouldn't it be immediately apparent to most people? After all, Mormon missionaries only ask investigators to pray for a feeling in order to know the entire church doctrine is true. Members should, then, be able to trust their feelings. But if they question, or think something doesn't feel right, they are taught that THOSE feelings aren't true feelings. Only feelings that confirm the church can be true feelings. So in reality, you cannot trust you own feelings - only what the church tells you to feel. All of this leads to a sense of cognitive dissonance and those true believing members get defensive about their beliefs because they don't like when someone points out the inconsistencies in their religion. So they either fight back through insults ("it's easier to question and give up than to do the right thing," etc...) or they avoid the topic altogether with anyone who doesn't confirm what they are supposed to believe.

I know there are some people out there who will feel that they do not fall into either of these broader categories, and that is great. If you believe in the policy wholeheartedly and do not feel defensive about it, or uncomfortable with it, then that's great. I am not seeking to tell anyone they are wrong. I am only reporting my observations and the questions I have for the church moving forward that this policy seems to directly conflict with. I clearly don't believe this was inspired by God, or even very well thought out by LDS church leaders. It is unfortunate that children may suffer due to these policies. I hope those who are hurting can find their own peace with the situation.

Wednesday, March 4, 2015

How American Work Culture Hurts Everyone (especially women)



I read an article today that really got me thinking about our work culture. The article was about Katherine Zaleski who used to be president of a company and in that role she discriminated against other women who were mothers, assuming they did not have the time to dedicate to their jobs fully. But then she became a mother and was faced with the dilemma of work/life balance. She decided to quit her office job and start a company with a friend that supports women in tech fields who want to work from home. Sounds like a noble effort to accommodate women's roles as both mothers and wage earners (article here).
      However, I do take some issue with the article as a whole. While I cringed at her admission of the terrible way she judged mothers, her "redemption" story also left me disappointed. While I do admire what she is trying to do now, by providing avenues for work from home (something coveted, competitive and often difficult to arrange), I am disappointed that she had to quit her office job. In fact, the whole article felt more like an advertisement for her new start-up company than anything that would actually help women who currently face the dilemma of work/life balance as mothers (unless they work in the technical industry and want to use her new company's services to find a new job).
      Women finding new employment after having a baby is not a novel idea. Often, however, the options are as limited as the pay. Work from home jobs, or jobs that are off-hours to balance child care with a partner, are jobs that generally aren't as lucrative. Instead of encouraging women to find new (limited) jobs that accommodate them, why can't we demand more flexibility from more industries and businesses? Research shows that being flexible with your employees on how and where they work shows an increase in productivity and job satisfaction.
       One point the Fortune article makes is that we put too much weight on actual hours logged in the office, and less on amount and quality of work produced. This is something that has always bothered me about American work culture, and it is something that really doesn't benefit anyone. Any worker (mother or otherwise) who has life obligation and is not able to "burn the midnight oil" might be seen as an underachiever. While I acknowledge that there are instances where staying late is needed, it should not be the norm. If someone manages their time well and works efficiently, they ought to be able to leave on time most days. If not, perhaps they are not the dedicated, hard-working, great-example-of-an-employee, but rather someone who is inefficient with their time and thus has to stay late to complete their work. Or perhaps the company is asking them to do too much, especially if they are salaried and only getting paid for a 40 hour/week commitment but then expected to do 60+ hours of work.
      Not only that, but with modern technology some employees are expected to always be reachable and to respond to emails/texts/calls no matter the time or day. While we like to think that all of this extra work effort is helping America (and Americans) there is little evidence that it is. Just take this report comparing the American economy to Germany's, and this guys who nicely sums up the difference in work culture between the two countries. For all our effort we are earning less and saving less, even if we are spending more. Which also begs the question, what are we spending our money on if all of our time is spent at work? With all of this emphasis on "work ethic" as only evidenced by number of hours spent at your work desk, it is no wonder that women feel anxious about and discriminated against for starting families. This is just another part of the intricate web that keeps women from having equal footing with men, and the fact that it is the women, and not men, who are expected to change their whole lives for their children is topic for a blog post all its own.
       In closing I would like to acknowledge that a lot of companies are moving to be more flexible. They are invested in their employees' quality of life and job satisfaction with the understanding that those employees will work harder and be more loyal. It's these flexible companies that are attracting the best, most qualified employees and are experiencing the most growth and profits for their efforts. So my hope and prayer is that it is only a matter of time before accommodating work schedules are the norm and no one has to choose between having a job and staying home with their children. As Katherine Zaleski does point out in her article "if you want something done ask a busy person to do it" and therefore, no one should be reluctant to hire a busy parent.

photo credit: <a href="http://www.flickr.com/photos/30353465@N07/8412601296">Portrait of a female executive</a> via <a href="http://photopin.com">photopin</a> <a href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nd/2.0/">(license)</a>